By Dr. Michael Henry
Joint pain, especially that caused by the development of arthritis, can significantly impact your day-to-day life. Luckily, there are now a number of effective treatment options available that can reduce pain and improve mobility and function.
Hyaluronic acid injections have gained popularity as a treatment for joint pain, particularly in conditions like osteoarthritis. Below, we'll compare hyaluronic acid injections to other common joint pain treatments to help you make an informed decision about the most suitable option for your needs.
Hyaluronic Acid Injections
Hyaluronic acid injections, also known as viscosupplementation, involve the injection of a gel-like substance directly into the affected joint. This treatment is most often used in the knee and hip joints, but can be used in other joints that have developed osteoarthritis.
Hyaluronic acid helps to lubricate the joint, reduce the friction of opposing surfaces rubbing together, and thus alleviate pain.
Pros:
Non-Surgical: Hyaluronic acid injections are a non-surgical option, making them appealing to individuals who want to avoid surgery. They are performed in-office.
Minimal Side Effects: They typically have minimal side effects, such as temporary swelling or discomfort at the injection site. There is no requirement to stay off your feet after an injection.
Improved Joint Function: Many patients experience improved joint function and reduced pain that can last for months.
Cons:
Temporary Relief: The effects of hyaluronic acid injections are usually temporary, requiring repeat treatments. The length of benefit depends on the severity of arthritis and the type of rehab that is completed following an injection. You will typically get 3-6 months of pain relief following treatment.
Varied Responses: Not all individuals respond equally well to this treatment.
Regenerative Therapies
Pros:
Stimulate Tissue Healing - Regenerative therapies such as Prolotherapy and Platelet-Rich-Plasma (PRP) injections, are treatments that stimulate a response from the body to start repairing their own damaged tissues.
Can Address the Root Cause - If pain and lack of function are due to structural soft tissue damage, the healing generated by regenerative therapies can address the root cause of these symptoms.
Longer Pain Relief - Compared to corticosteroids, regenerative injections tend to provide longer lasting pain relief.
Low Risk - Unlike corticosteroids, regenerative injections are very safe, especially when performed under ultrasound guidance.
Cons:
Multiple Treatments Needed: Often more than one treatment is needed to get the full effects of regenerative therapies. Treatments are usually spaced 3-6 weeks apart, and typically range from 2-5 treatments needed.
Can Cause Temporary Discomfort: Following treatment, there is often short-term discomfort as a result of the inflammatory healing response triggered by the treatment. Peak response from regenerative therapies is usually months after the initial treatment
Corticosteroid Injections
Corticosteroid injections involve the injection of an anti-inflammatory medication directly into the affected joint. They are often used to manage joint pain associated with conditions like rheumatoid arthritis and osteoarthritis.
Pros:
Rapid Pain Relief: Corticosteroid injections often provide fast relief, in the span of days to a few weeks.
Anti-Inflammatory: They can effectively reduce inflammation in the joint.
Cons:
Temporary Relief: The pain relief from corticosteroid injections is typically temporary - in some instances your relief may be shorter-lived than with hyaluronic acid treatment.
Potential Side Effects: Long-term or frequent use may be associated with side effects such as joint damage or thinning of nearby tissues. Because of these risks, the frequency at which you can use this treatment is generally limited.
Band-aid Solution: Corticosteroids do not address the root cause of dysfunction and pain, and thus cannot be relied on for long-term relief as the sole treatment. At the very least, physical therapy is needed to prolong the benefits of treatment.
Physical Therapy and Exercise
Physical therapy and exercise programs are designed to improve joint strength, flexibility, and function. They are often recommended as part of a comprehensive approach to managing joint pain alongside other treatments.
Pros:
Non-Invasive: Physical therapy and exercise are non-invasive and can be tailored to individual needs.
Long-Term Benefits: When done consistently, they provide long-term benefits by strengthening the joint, ligaments, and surrounding muscles
.
Cons:
Require Time and Effort: Achieving noticeable results may take time and consistent effort.
Not Suitable for Severe Cases: In severe joint damage, these treatments may not be sufficient on their own.
Surgical Interventions
In cases of severe joint damage, surgical interventions such as joint replacement or arthroscopy may be necessary to provide lasting relief.
Pros:
Lasting Relief: Joint replacement surgeries can provide lasting pain relief and improved joint function.
Cons:
Invasive: Surgical interventions are invasive and involve a recovery period.
Risks: Surgery comes with potential risks and complications.
The choice of treatment for your joint pain depends on your exact condition, the severity of it, other factors of health such as your likelihood of recovery, your preferences, and what is considered best practice in your case.
Hyaluronic acid injections offer a non-surgical option with few side effects and no long-term risks of repeat use, making them suitable for many individuals. However, consultation with your Naturopathic Doctor/Medical Doctor is necessary to determine the most appropriate treatment plan for you.
Comments